A Comparative Study of “The History Boys,” and “3 Idiots” free essay sample

The education system has influenced our attitude in the reality life. In fact, school life occupies a large amount in our life, so that there is a huge affectation to our daily life. Besides, there are two resources to support my point of view which is comparing the movie and the book that I choice to study their meaning reflect to reality life by using â€Å"The History Boys† and â€Å"3 Idiots†. Both of the theme are talking about the school life and the education system which is bored and conservatism. In the following part, different theme as well as action and thought will be illustrated with Marxism as the theoretical framework. First of all, the education isn’t expect the student`s increase their knowledge anymore, but only study for examination. The goal of student to study suppose for enhance knowledge in order to face their own future, but the education system are invisibly forcing them only study for the score that gain in examination. The definition of the â€Å"words† is used to express the meaning to the student. However, the model answer of the exam which is exactly the definition, so that the students can only mindless cramming the definition without understand and use it in the reality life. Besides, it can also prove that student by forcing to ignore the process of study, but only care on the result. Learning wasn’t expecting the personal knowledge but in order to our personal needs. According to the â€Å"3 Idiots†, â€Å"there is one scene in the classroom, the professor is teaching his student of what is the meaning of â€Å"Machine† and he is going to ask someone to answer him. In that moment, one of the main character called â€Å"Rancho† answer him in a simple language, but the professor dissatisfied his answer, it is just because â€Å"Rancho† not answering the definition tough by him and he said that student should remember all the textbook definition for the examination more important than learn it in our daily life experience. † ( Rajkumar Hiran, 2009, 23:06-25:25). In the other side according to the â€Å"The History Boys†, there are two teachers teaching the boys in different method. One of the teachers called â€Å"Irwin†, he teaching the boys should be remember the definition of the textbook and backwards thinking in order to handle their exam. After the boys discuss what they had learned from the book, Irwin said their answers were first class and he has said â€Å"Bristol welcomes you with open arms. Manchester longs to have you. You can walk into Leeds†. (Alan Bennett, 2004, p. 24) We can see that Irwin prefers his student follow this study method to going the top university. The part that we mention before which is the action of the characterization. The professor of the â€Å"3 Idiots† and â€Å"Irwin† both are the same class character that is the teacher and they are advocating their student to remember the textbook definition only. However, the target will only set in the university. It can prove that the education system is usually using this teaching method to teach, if we don’t change back to the original study pattern. When we finish our school life, we are a machine that can remember all the textbook definition only. In addition, student`s study in different way will gain the life principles or values differently. Some of them are studying mindless cramming to the definition of the textbook; they even don’t know the meaning of the words. Besides, some of the student would not only study the textbook, they are willing to study outside even study in the experience that they been through. According to the â€Å"3 Idiots†, â€Å"there are one of the main characters called â€Å"chatur†, he is the introductory speaker at the teacher day, the librarian are going to write the speech for him to memorize it. Also, the librarian ready to explain the meaning of the words that he don’t understand as well, but he said that he is prefer to mindless cramming the speech, since that he has measure in the first one of the examination result by using this study method, so that he said there are no need to know the meaning of those word. † (Rajkumar Hiran, 2009, 1:00:00-1:04:10). In the other side according to â€Å"The History Boys†, one of teachers called â€Å"Hector†, â€Å"he is using the way that not normally to teach his student that is using drama or song as a part of teaching. Moreover, they will also speak with each other by using French and acting the drama in the class. Hector wants to the boys can learn the poem meaning when they acting in the poem situation. † (Alan Bennett, 2004, pp. 12-14) The part that we mention before which is the thought of the characterization. â€Å"chatur† and the boys both are the character as the student. The different between them that is â€Å"chatur† is using the mindless cramming to remember the textbook knowledge without the meaning. That is only for short memory; it is not enhance your knowledge for your reality experience. Furthermore, there are effective methods to study that are using the special way. Performing the drama in the class in order to study the poem in your own situation when you are acting the character of the poem, so that you might be can explore another meaning of the poem without only reading. The last but not less, traditional education are forcing the students accept the tradition thought. The hidden rules of the school is a kind of the reflect to the reality world. The life of school must be occupied in a large of amount, so that student lifestyle must e affect by the education system. There is one of the examples of the hidden rules in the school. According to the â€Å"3 Idiots†, â€Å"the three main characters has graduate and they are going to take the graduation photos, but the headmaster has set the student should be seat according to their rank. Besides, Rachor wondering the grading system is similar with the caste system or the slaves system. † (Rajkumar Hiran, 2009, pp. 1:23:35-1:24:44). In the other side according to â€Å"The History Boys†, â€Å"there are a girl that see Hector has do some indecent movement to his student, Headmaster has noticed that Hector is a Homosexual and he is going to punish Hector which is bring his retire forwardly and arrange his class sharing with Irwin. † (Alan Bennett, 2004, pp. 51-52). The part that we mention before which is the action of the characterization. Two of the characters are the headmasters. It has brought the idea to the student that seating according to their rank reflects that your ability in the society will certificate your level in a group. The student might be think that there is in a must of things are setting as a grading system, so that is a misunderstanding. Furthermore, Headmaster has a bad reaction when he noticed Hector is a homosexual who is reflect the society does not accept the homosexual. The student might be avoiding the topic to be discussed and if they are one of them, they are not willing to admit it. So that they are forcing to follow the hidden rule of the school since that they are have not the other choice. In the summary, the education system affects the student to ignore the process but focus on the result only. In fact, using the special way like Hector class which is acting the characters of the poem in class are more effectiveness to the student to absorb the knowledge instead of mindless cramming the definition of the textbook. Those will only for the short memory it. The reaction of the teacher or the behavior also an important reflection to the society also, since the school life occupy our life a large amount, when the student has gradated and going to work in the society, they will follow the style on how they survive in the school. Lastly, school is the affective place for all of us, the education system which is the core of it, so that it is an important element on how a person grow up in a what type of person.